“Luda and Milena”, by Lara Vapnyar

Our reading for December, Lara Vapnyar’s “Luda and Milena”, is formally, linguistically and thematically simpler than the previous two we have discussed, yet it is an extraordinary short story that should not be dismissed on the basis of its simplicity. Originally published in The New Yorker, it was later included in Vapnyar’s second and most recent collection of short stories, Broccoli and Other Tales of Food and Love, among others that share with it the intersecting themes mentioned in the explicit title. The characters of this story, Luda and Milena, are typical of Vapnyar’s work, that is, they are Russian immigrants to the United States. As the author affirms in a number of interviews, she writes about what she knows. Vapnyar immigrated to the United States from Russia in 1994, when she was 23 years old, an experience apparently still quite vivid in her memory and engrained in her literary imagination.

In “Luda and Milena” the author uses the setting of an ESL (English as a Second Language) class to introduce the reader to the two rivaling protagonists, but this setting comes to occupy a secondary importance in the narration. The same could be said of the plot, since the narrative of this story clearly focuses on Luda and Milena’s impressions, reactions, perspectives, needs, motivations and emotions. This E.S.L. classroom is a pretext to bring together the protagonists and to provide the reader with a local color snapshot of immigrant Brooklyn, or with an interesting statement about the divisions and sympathies between different cultural groups in the urban United States, depending on the reader’s perspective, of course. Despite Angie’s “enthusiasm”, the dynamic between the individual students is anything but harmonious. For instance, Luda and Milena are from the same country, but they only feel hostile toward each other.

This leads me to conclude that the Culture Collector for this month’s meeting has a lot of interesting material. I would encourage him or her, and all the participants, to think a bit about the information in the story pertaining to the “immigrant experience”. I think we can explore a number of different notions in relation to immigration, particularly in the United States. It doesn’t matter if these notions are real or imagined, based on prejudice or on experience. In “Luda and Milena”, a large proportion of the narrative is dedicated to monitoring these two silently fueding middle-aged women and their perspectives of each other and of the other students in the class. Try to isolate the moments of objective description and those of the women’s thoughts. Upon careful inspections, I think you will see that the story offers us a great deal of insight into the situation of its characters and that its simplicity can fool the reader if he or she generally equates simplicity with a lack of quality or depth. That said, the Characterizer also has quite a job ahead of him or her – there is an immense amount of information about Luda and Milena. I look forward to hearing your thoughts at the meeting on Wednesday.

Normally, I would refrain from using a term or idea such as the “immigrant experience” because of its tendency to gloss over a much harsher reality and homogenize the experience of individuals who have little in common aside from having been born in a different country.  I would also refrain from venturing an explanation of a work of literature based on knowledge of the biography of its author. But this month’s reading provides an exception to my general rule. I believe that “Luda and Milena” is a simple but well written piece of fiction by a storyteller who has a story to tell us (in our own language, not hers!) about an experience that would be difficult for us to know of if not for her will and capacity to tell it. I hope you enjoy this story by Lara Vapnyar.

This entry was posted in Cycle 2012/13 December Reading and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to “Luda and Milena”, by Lara Vapnyar

  1. José Luis says:

    First of all, Peter, thanks for your Lara Vapnyar’s December’s short story. I like it very much, because it offers a great deal of hidden and non explicit information about the lifes of the inmigrant people: the support of the families, the loneliness of the older members of the group, etc. And I must confess I love the way the author shows us the rivalry between the two main female characters -beyond their same roots: Russia, the antagonism between them is actually total-

  2. Carmen González says:

    Yesterday I have had the feeling that I was ¨espesa¨. Well, actually , my conversation skills in english are very poor, sorry!. Just I´ll try to say something in written, hope it helps.
    On my opinion, Milena represents for Luda ¨the lover tipe of woman¨ and Luda for Milena the wife prototype. Both of them have being enemies on the shadow, without a direct oportunity for confrontation, they have figth for their adult life a silent battle. They recognize each other since the very first moment they met at ESL What a wonderfull oportunity for real figth!. Aron is the excuse for figthing but does not matter. The only thing that matters is to win, to defeat ¨the other¨.
    Merry Chrismas for all of you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s